Ten spots, ranked the same way we rank the Best of LI — by the actual public review record, not by who bought an ad. Rockville Centre's Sunrise Highway brunch row, a 70-year Carle Place egg counter, and a Floral Park tea house that books out on weekends.
📷 Long Island
How this list works: same method as Best of LI 2026 — every candidate inside Nassau County is scored on its public Google review record (rating weighted by review count, minimum 300 reviews), then the editors sanity-check the top of the board. No votes, no sponsorships, no pay-to-play.
No town in Nassau takes brunch more seriously than Rockville Centre. Mojo RVC and Pappa Gallo sit a block apart on Sunrise Highway and between them hold nearly 25,000 reviews at ★ 4.9 — the two strongest review records of any brunch spot on Long Island. Come for the full weekend-production brunch; expect a wait at peak Sunday hours. A few blocks south on Merrick Road, The Pantry is the quieter, breakfast-first alternative when the row is slammed.
Thomas's Ham & Eggery in Carle Place has been flipping eggs on Old Country Road for more than 70 years — it's the county's standard-bearer for the no-frills, get-there-early breakfast. Around the corner, Carle Place Diner covers the classic Long Island diner brunch: enormous menu, booths, coffee refills without asking.
The Cuban in Garden City turns brunch into a party — Cuban plates and live-music energy on Stewart Avenue. Swing the Teapot in Floral Park is the opposite move: a small tea house doing a proper pot-and-scones service that regulars guard jealously. Book ahead on weekends.
The Good Life in Massapequa Park and Whiskey Down Diner in Farmingdale both do the modern-comfort brunch well — and Brixx & Barley earns the Long Beach slot: brunch first, then the boardwalk two blocks south. Pair it with a stop from our Long Beach town guide.
Across both counties, our Best of LI #1 for brunch is Hatch on Main Street in Huntington (★ 4.7, 4,000+ reviews) — just over the Suffolk line. See the full island-wide top 10, plus 13 more categories.
Brunch first, then what? Check what's happening on Long Island this weekend, browse the handpicked restaurant reviews, or pick a town — Rockville Centre, Garden City, and Long Beach all have their own guides with the top-rated spots nearby.
Every Thursday morning — the weekend's top events, the good news, this week's restaurant pick, and the #1 in Best of LI. Free forever.