Best Restaurants Long Island
Curated dining recommendations from across Long Island
Ram's Head Inn
📍 108 Ram Island Dr, Shelter Island Heights, NY 11965
Dating back to 1929, this Shelter Island gem offers sweeping waterfront views that are romantic 24/7/365. For Valentine's weekend, they're pulling out all the stops with special prix-fixe menus. The perfect escape for couples seeking classic elegance over crowds.
View Details🍕 Best Pizza on Long Island
Vote Now →
1
Umberto's of New Hyde Park
📍 New Hyde Park
Legendary grandma slice and award-winning Sicilian that's been a local favorite since 1965.
2
Gino's Pizzeria of Commack
📍 Commack
Wood-fired perfection with a crispy, charred crust that pizza purists dream about.
3
King Umberto
📍 Elmont
Family-owned since 1991. Their vodka slice is legendary among pizza aficionados.
🥯 Best Bagels on Long Island
Vote Now →
1
Bagel Boss
📍 Multiple Locations
The OG Long Island bagel chain. Hand-rolled, kettle-boiled, baked fresh daily.
2
Bagel Chalet
📍 Commack + 3 more
Hot breakfast sandwiches, chopped salads, acai bowls, and perfect bagels at 4 locations.
3
Goldberg's Famous Bagels
📍 Oceanside
Known for their flagels (flat bagels) and incredible whitefish salad.
🍳 Best Brunch Spots
Vote Now →
1
Toast & Co.
📍 Huntington Village
Bottomless mimosas, avocado toast done right, and the fluffiest pancakes on the island.
2
Hatch
📍 Huntington
"Peace, love, and bacon." 2025's Best Brunch winner with a bright, chic vibe that screams mimosas.
3
Starr Boggs
📍 Westhampton Beach
Refined coastal fare with innovative dishes showcasing the region's best seafood and local produce.
🌙 Best Date Night Spots
Vote Now →
1
Salumi Tapas & Wine Bar
📍 Massapequa
Romantic atmosphere, shareable plates, and an incredible wine list.
2
Insignia Prime Steak
📍 Smithtown
Upscale steakhouse with impeccable service and stunning presentations.
3
Mirabelle Restaurant
📍 St. James
Elegant French cuisine in a cozy, sophisticated setting.
☕ Best Coffee Shops
Vote Now →
1
Southdown Coffee
📍 Huntington + 5 more
Long Island's beloved micro-roasters. Six locations, in-house roasting, serious coffee culture.
2
North Fork Coffee Co.
📍 Greenport
Wine country vibes with exceptional lattes. Lavender honey latte is TikTok-famous.
3
Grindstone Coffee & Donuts
📍 Sag Harbor
Hamptons' favorite. Famous for their espresso and fresh-made donuts.